Switching from Lead-Antimony to Lead-Calcium Alloys in Battery Grid Casting: What Manufacturers Need to Know
By the author of the Amazon Bestseller Book 'Batteries Demystified', Podcaster, & Expert in Lead Acid Battery Manufacturing Processes and Machines
🔧⚡ Switching to Lead-Calcium Alloys? Proceed with Caution… ⚠️
Many battery manufacturers are eyeing lead-calcium alloys as antimony prices rise—but here’s the truth:
👉 It’s not just a metal swap. It’s a mindset shift.
🔍 If you're in the battery manufacturing space—especially in automotive, inverter, or VRLA segments—you must know:
Why Pb-Ca is excellent in some places but a disaster in others
What tiny impurity can sabotage your entire batch?
How one temperature misstep can cripple your grid strength
🎯 This isn’t just metallurgy. It’s precision engineering.
📖 I’ve unpacked the critical dos, don’ts, and must-knows in a detailed article:
💡If you're thinking about switching alloys, this is a must-read before you melt that first lead alloy ingot.
As the price of antimony continues to rise, battery manufacturers are exploring more cost-effective alternatives, one of which is using lead-calcium (Pb-Ca) alloys for grid casting. However, switching from lead-antimony (Pb-Sb) to lead-calcium alloys is not a simple material swap. It involves significant changes to the manufacturing process, equipment setup, and alloy handling practices.
In this article, I’ll outline key considerations for battery manufacturers evaluating the shift to lead-calcium alloys, especially those producing automotive, stationary, and cycling batteries.
Why Consider Lead-Calcium Alloys?
Battery manufacturers, especially in the small-scale industry (SSI) sector, often ask whether lead-calcium alloys can be used instead of traditional lead-antimony alloys, particularly for e-rickshaw and stationary batteries.
While many are comfortable using Pb-Sb alloys containing selenium for automotive batteries, the question is whether Pb-Ca-based grids can match the performance and reliability of selenium-containing Pb-Sb grids.
The short answer is yes—lead-calcium alloys can be effective, but only when accompanied by process adjustments.
Applications: Where Lead-Calcium Alloys Fit Best
Let’s break down the usage suitability by application:
✅ Automotive Batteries
Lead-calcium alloys are suitable for both positive and negative plates. When manufactured correctly, they offer reliable performance and longevity.
✅ Stationary Batteries (UPS/Inverter)
Lead-calcium alloys may be used for negative plates, but lead-antimony alloys are to be used for positive tubular plates. This hybrid approach works well for UPS and inverter applications.
🚫 Cycling Applications (E-rickshaws, Golf Carts, Solar)
Avoid lead-calcium alloys in high-cycle applications. Lead-antimony alloys offer better performance and cycle life. Calcium-based alloys may present reliability issues in stationary batteries used for solar photovoltaic systems.
✅ VRLA Batteries
Lead-calcium alloys are already widely used for both plates, with a few exceptions where manufacturers still use selenium-containing low antimonial lead alloy for the positives.
Alloy Composition: Getting It Right
Calcium
Ideal range: 0.05 to 0.08%, with 0.06% being optimal.
<0.045% leads to weak grids; >0.08% reduces creep resistance, shortening cycle life.
Tin
Improves creep resistance, reduces passivation, and enhances corrosion resistance.
Recommended: 0.6 to 0.8%; max benefit up to 1.5%. More than that adds cost without benefits.
Aluminum
Prevents calcium oxidation during melting.
Optimal range: 0.015–0.03%, ideally around 0.03%.
Silver (Optional)
Improves corrosion resistance only if tin <1%.
Beneficial at ~0.05%, but excessive silver leads to gassing and brittle grids.
VRLA Grid Composition Snapshot
Plate Type Positive
Calcium (%): 0.06 to 0.08
Tin (%): 1.5
Aluminum (%): 0.015 to 0.03
Plate Type Negative
Calcium (%): 0.08 to 0.12
Tin (%): 0.3 to 0.6
Aluminum (%): 0.03
Impurity Management: A Must
· Bismuth: Hard to remove, affects corrosion and passivation. Limit to ≤0.05%.
· Iron: Must be kept below 0.0005%.
· Sodium Sulfate: Avoid sodium sulfate in flooded batteries when using Pb-Ca alloys, as it accelerates corrosion.
Process & Casting Adjustments
Switching to Pb-Ca requires more than material substitution—a process overhaul.
Preventing Antimony Contamination
Avoid introducing Pb-Sb trimmings, sweepings, or ingots into the Pb-Ca melting pot. Antimony reacts with calcium to form calcium antimonide (CaSb₃), leading to dross and calcium loss. If contamination occurs, the entire alloy batch may need to be reprocessed.
Temperature Settings
Furnace Temperature Settings
Lead Pot: >500°C
Ladle Temperature Settings
450 to 500°C
Mold Upper Zone Temperature Settings
170 to 190°C
Mold Lower Zone Temperature Settings
210°C
Stabilize temperature parameters once acceptable grids are consistently produced.
The temperature from the feed pipe to the ladle has to be slightly higher than the pot temperature. The ingredients, especially calcium, may precipitate if the temperature is lower, leading to less calcium in the cast grids. It is advisable to ensure that the feed pipe temperature is between 500 and 520 degrees centigrade and not lower.
Too high a temperature causes oxidation, and low temperatures lead to calcium precipitation. Considering the sensitive nature of lead calcium alloys in temperature control, periodic calibration of all temperature measuring instruments is necessary. The sensor probe ends must be cleaned to ensure the temperature is correctly measured.
Pot & Furnace Design
Use ‘deep melting pots’ to reduce surface oxidation.
Apply charcoal cover to:
· Prevent calcium oxidation
· Retain heat
· Lower the power consumption
Test alloy composition every shift (8 hours) in continuous operations or daily in single-shift setups.
Handling and Cooling
Grids made from lead-calcium alloys:
· Are softer
· Are ejected at higher temperatures
· May require additional ejection pins in the mould
· Should be air-cooled or hardened in temperature-controlled rooms for structural strength
Best Practices for Grid Casting with Pb-Ca Alloys
· Use a gravity-fed ‘furnace on top pot’ for consistent flow.
· Melt trimmings separately and check the composition before reuse.
· Avoid frequent drossing—this leads to calcium loss.
· Train operators in cork spraying—higher temperatures reduce spray life and demand precise application.
· Maintain tight temperature control to ensure consistent alloy behavior.
· Cool grids after casting using a strong blast of air after the grids are cast.
· A heat treatment of the grids in the aging chamber before the pasting operation is reportedly helpful.
Conclusion
Lead-calcium alloys present a viable alternative to antimony-based alloys, especially in automotive and select stationary applications. However, successful implementation depends on strict process control, impurity management, and awareness of application limitations.
Manufacturers must treat this transition not just as a material substitution, but as a system-level change involving casting parameters, alloy handling, operator training, and process discipline.
TO GRAB YOUR FREE COLOR COPY OF THE BATTERY MANUFACTURING PROCESS FLOW CHART, CLICK ON THE LINK BELOW:
✔️https://ramesh-natarajan.ck.page/1d1909eaef
You can visit my website to 👀read similar blogs and articles, 👂hear my podcasts, and 🎥see videos about batteries and related subjects by clicking the link below:
To ✍️ write to me with your comments and suggestions, please note my email below:
✔️ rameshnkailad@gmail.com
To buy my books 📒, please click on one of the links given below:
✔️https://relinks.me/9390661692 ️or https://relinks.me/B0BNXL1854